VERTEX 2000

REFEREE REPORT FORM
  1. Rate the novelty and interest to the community (i.e., high, medium, low):

    2. Does the manuscript contain original and self-consistent ideas?.

  2. Does the manuscript contain subject matter that might/should be omitted? If so, what?

    3.  

  3. Is it clearly presented and well organized?

    4.  

  4. Does it give adequate references/citations to related work and are they up to date?

    5.  

  5. Is the English satisfactory?
  6. Are the illustrations and tables necessary and adequate?

    7.  

  7. Is the abstract informative and does it cover the content?

    8.  

  8. Are the conclusions sound and justified?

    9. .

  9. Please indicate your recommendation regarding publication (check one box):

q the paper is acceptable in present form

q the paper is/might be acceptable with minor technical revision

q the paper is/might be acceptable with major technical revision

q the paper is inappropriate for publication in an International Scientific Journal

_________________________________________________________________________________

Additional Comments: